Edgekeeper vs a Notion trading journal
A Notion journal is a database you designed, and that is its strength and its ceiling. It will hold anything you tell it to hold. What it will not do is know that your firm's trailing drawdown floor stops rising at a specific point above your starting balance, or work out what today's loss has done to it.
What a Notion trading journal does better
- Complete freedom of structure. If you want a field, you add a field.
- It is already in your workflow, next to your notes and your plan, and it costs you nothing extra.
- Templates are plentiful and a good one gets you journaling this afternoon.
What Edgekeeper does differently
Arithmetic you do not have to maintain
R-multiples, expectancy, profit factor, drawdown, streaks, session and setup breakdowns, and the prop-account floor all come out of one place. In Notion each of those is a formula you wrote, which means each of them is a formula you have to keep correct as your trading changes.
It knows what an open trade is
A trade with no exit is open, not a zero. That distinction runs through every statistic — open trades are not counted as losses, and a stop-less import is not averaged in as a genuine 0R trade. Hand-rolled spreadsheets and databases get this wrong almost by default, because a blank cell reads as zero.
The rules are enforced, not written down
A Notion page can hold your trading rules. It cannot tell you that this trade breaks one, at the moment you log it, and tag it so the cost shows up in your own statistics later.
- Your journal is mostly narrative and you value writing over measurement.
- You genuinely enjoy building the system, and maintaining it is not a chore you will abandon.
- You do not trade a funded account with published limits.
- You have a drawdown floor to respect and want it computed rather than tracked by hand.
- You have already built the Notion journal twice and stopped using it twice.
- You want statistics you can trust without auditing your own formulas.
Questions
Can I import a Notion database?
Export it to CSV and import that. Column names do not need to match anything — the importer maps them, and shows a column editor when it cannot work one out.
Can I still keep written notes?
Yes. Every trade takes a note, screenshots attach to it, and the weekly review is prose as well as figures. The difference is that the numbers beside the notes are computed.
What does it cost to start?
Nothing, and there is no card at signup. The free tier holds unlimited trades and all the core analytics.
Try it against your own history
Free covers unlimited trades · 1 prop account with your firm’s real rules · 3 rules of your own, enforced · full core analytics · 3 screenshots. Pro is $15/mo or $129 a year when you want the depth. Import a CSV and see what your last hundred trades say.
Start free